If you’re involved in a personal injury claim, one of your biggest concerns is probably: How much of my settlement will I receive once my lawyer takes their cut? The answer usually comes down to something called a contingency fee — a system where your lawyer only gets paid if they win your case.

Understanding how these fees work is critical to making informed decisions about your legal representation and to ensure you’re not surprised when that final check arrives.

Most personal injury lawyers take between 33% and 40% of the total settlement amount. But that number can vary depending on the complexity of your case, whether it goes to trial, and local regulations. In this guide, we will answer the question, “What percentage does a lawyer take from a settlement?” by:

Defining contingency fees
Outlining the factors that influence the typical attorney fee percentage
Explaining how settlement payouts are calculated and paid
And sharing some tips for hiring the right personal injury lawyer

Table of Contents

Understanding Contingency Fees

A contingency fee, sometimes referred to as a “no win, no fee” model, is a type of payment arrangement where your attorney only gets paid if they win your case or secure a settlement. Instead of billing by the hour, they take a percentage of the total amount recovered. If they don’t win, you typically owe nothing for their services.

Contingency fees are common in personal injury law because they provide clients with access to legal representation without requiring them to pay upfront. Here’s a basic breakdown of the typical attorney fee percentage:

Standard contingency fee: 33% (one-third of your settlement)
If the case goes to trial: Often increases to 40% due to the additional time, resources, and risk involved

Factors That Influence the Attorney’s Percentage

Several key factors can affect how much your lawyer ultimately takes from your settlement. While 33% is the typical attorney fee percentage, that number isn’t set in stone.

Case Complexity

More complicated personal injury cases — like those involving multiple parties, disputed liability, or severe injuries — often require more time, expert testimony, and investigative work. As a result, attorneys may charge a higher percentage to account for the increased workload and financial risk.

Whether the Case Goes to Trial

If your case settles out of court, you might only owe 33%. But if it goes to trial, expect that number to increase. Trials involve:

More preparation
Court filings
Witness prep
Expert testimony
Extended time commitments

This extra effort justifies a 40% fee or more in some instances.

Lawyer’s Experience and Track Record

An attorney with decades of experience and a strong track record of winning high-value cases may charge more than a less experienced lawyer. While it may be tempting to go with the lowest fee possible, remember: you often get what you pay for.

A skilled, reputable lawyer can often secure a much higher settlement — even after taking a slightly higher percentage—than someone less experienced might negotiate.

State Bar Rules and Local Regulations

State bar associations often regulate how much attorneys can charge in contingency fee cases. For example, in Florida, the Bar provides detailed guidelines limiting contingency fees based on how much is recovered and when.

Always check your retainer agreement and make sure your lawyer is following your state’s rules. These regulations help protect clients from excessive legal fees.

Additional Legal Costs You Should Expect

Beyond the lawyer’s fee, there are case-related expenses that may also come out of your final settlement. These are separate from the contingency fee percentage and typically include:

Filing fees
Court reporter and transcript costs
Expert witness fees
Medical record retrieval
Investigation services
Postage and photocopying

Who Pays These Costs?

In most cases, your attorney will front these costs throughout the legal process. Once your case is resolved, those expenses are reimbursed from your settlement before you receive your portion. This system allows you to pursue a claim without having to pay upfront for critical services.

Keep in mind: even if you don’t win your case, you may still be responsible for some out-of-pocket costs unless otherwise agreed in your contract.

How Settlement Payouts Are Handled

Once your case is settled or a judgment is awarded, the defendant (or their insurer) sends a check to your attorney’s office, not directly to you. This check is usually deposited into a trust or escrow account and disbursed as follows:

Legal fees are deducted first
Case-related costs are reimbursed
The remaining balance will be sent to you

The length of this process can vary depending on bank processing times and whether any liens need to be paid (e.g., to hospitals or insurance).

Your attorney should provide a clear breakdown of all deductions and expenses, so you know exactly where every dollar is going.

Methods Used to Calculate Personal Injury Settlements

Knowing how your settlement is calculated can help you better understand the overall value of your case — and how your attorney’s percentage will affect your final payout.

There are two commonly used methods to calculate non-economic damages (like pain and suffering):

Multiplier Method

With this approach, your total economic damages (e.g., medical bills, lost wages) are multiplied by a number, usually between 1.5 and 5, based on the severity of your injuries.

Example:

Medical bills: $15,000
Multiplier: 3 (for moderate injuries)
Pain & suffering: $15,000 × 3 = $45,000
Total settlement = $60,000

This method is widely used in car accident and personal injury cases.

Per Diem Method

The per diem approach assigns a daily dollar amount to the pain and suffering you experienced and multiplies that by the number of recovery days.

Example:

$150 per day × 100 days of recovery = $15,000 in non-economic damages

This method is less common than the multiplier method, but may be used when there’s a clear start and end to your pain and recovery.

Can You Negotiate a Better Attorney Fee?

Yes — in some cases, you can negotiate the contingency fee with your lawyer before signing a retainer agreement.

Situations where attorneys may agree to a lower fee:

Your case is very strong and likely to settle quickly
Minimal investigation or court appearances are required
You’re referred by another attorney or a past client

Tips to Lower Your Legal Costs

Ask about a tiered fee structure (e.g., 30% if settled, 40% if trial)
Review the agreement carefully before signing
Get a second opinion if the rate feels unusually high

Just remember: while saving money is important, choosing the right lawyer can make or break your case. A slightly higher fee may be worth it if the attorney has a proven record of winning large settlements.

Comparing the Cost of Legal Help vs. Doing It Alone

It might seem tempting to handle your personal injury claim on your own, especially if the case appears straightforward. But statistics show that settlement amounts are often significantly higher when an experienced personal injury lawyer is involved.

Reasons why a lawyer often increases your net payout:

Knows how to negotiate with insurance adjusters
Can identify all recoverable damages
Understands tactics used by the defense
Avoids common legal mistakes that could cost you thousands

Even after paying a 33%–40% fee, many clients walk away with more money than they would have earned by going solo.

Frequently Asked Questions

On average, what percentage do injury lawyers take from a settlement?

Most personal injury lawyers take 33% of the total settlement, but this can increase to 40% or more if the case goes to trial.

Do all personal injury lawyers use contingency fees?

The vast majority do, especially in cases involving accidents and injuries. Some attorneys may offer hourly billing or flat fees, but contingency is the norm.

What if I lose my case?

If your lawyer works on a contingency basis, you typically don’t owe attorney fees. However, you may still be responsible for out-of-pocket costs unless otherwise stated in your agreement.

Are there caps on attorney fees?

Yes, some states (like Florida and California) have statutory limits on how much a lawyer can charge, especially in cases involving minors or medical malpractice.

How are expenses handled?

Most attorneys advance the costs and deduct them from the final settlement before issuing your payment. Always request a detailed accounting of deductions.

Tips for Hiring the Right Injury Lawyer

Hiring the right personal injury lawyer can significantly impact both your settlement and the overall experience throughout the process.

Here’s what to look for:

Verify the contingency agreement and ask for a copy in writing
Discuss additional costs and how they’ll be handled
Ask for references or testimonials from past clients
Look for board certification or specialization in personal injury law
Check for a track record of successful settlements and verdicts
Prioritize clear communication and transparency

Know What You’re Owed, Know What You’ll Keep

Still asking yourself, “What percentage does a lawyer take from a settlement”?

Before signing any legal agreement, schedule a candid consultation with your lawyer. During this conversation, they will answer all your questions and explain how your settlement will be distributed. While contingency fees are common and fair, transparency is key.

To recap:

Most lawyers take 33% to 40%
Additional legal costs are separate and reimbursed after settlement
Hiring a good lawyer can often lead to a higher net payout, even after fees

If you’re considering filing a personal injury claim, don’t go it alone. Contact Naqvi Injury Law today for a free consultation. We will help you maximize your recovery and keep you informed every step of the way.

Related Content: